Skip to content 
More than five decades have passed since three-year-old Cheryl Grimmer vanished from Fairy Meadow Beach in New South Wales, Australia, on 12 January 1970. What should have been a carefree day at the seaside turned into one of the nation’s most enduring mysteries. Despite multiple reviews, international attention, and even a million-dollar reward, the case remains unsolved.
Recently, Cheryl’s family expressed renewed anger after learning that police did not formally interview three potential eyewitnesses who came forward following a BBC podcast. For the family, it felt like another painful setback in their search for answers.
The Day Cheryl Disappeared
Cheryl Grimmer had emigrated from Bristol, UK, with her parents and three brothers only a year before her disappearance. On that summer day in 1970, the family went to Fairy Meadow Beach, about 50 miles (80 km) south of Sydney.
Cheryl and her seven-year-old brother Ricki were in the changing rooms near the beach. Ricki remembers looking away for just a few moments before realizing his younger sister was gone. Despite immediate searches by family and beachgoers, no trace of Cheryl was found. Authorities quickly suspected an abduction, but no arrests at the time led to a conviction.
A Painstaking Review Yields No Breakthrough
In recent years, New South Wales Police conducted a four-year review of the case. Cheryl’s family had hoped it would reveal new leads, especially after renewed public interest sparked by the Fairy Meadow true-crime podcast, which has been downloaded more than five million times.
Instead, police informed the family that the review uncovered no new evidence capable of securing a conviction. To the family, this felt like yet another chapter of disappointment in a case already burdened by decades of unanswered questions.