Melissa Sue Anderson was âcold and aloofâ..
From seasons one to seven of Little House on the Prairie, Melissa Sue Anderson won the hearts of fans as the beautiful blonde-haired Mary, the eldest child of Charles and Caroline Ingalls.
However, her co-stars found it challenging to connect with her. Both Melissa Gilbert and Alison Arngrim shared in their autobiographies that Melissa Sue Anderson ânicknamed âMissyâ on set â often came across as cold and aloof during her time on the show. Yet, when you look at photos of the cast together, itâs hard to believe there was any distance between them.
Rumors swirled among the crew that Missyâs overprotective mother contributed to her tendency to keep to herself.
But Nellie and Laura became best friends
Alison Arngrim played the original mean girl, Nellie Oleson, the arch-nemesis of good girl Laura Ingalls, portrayed by Melissa Gilbert. But behind the scenes, it was a different story! Alison and Melissa hit it off and became the best of friends.
When the cameras stopped rolling, they were like real sisters, sharing laughs and creating memories that went beyond the show.
Off-set, they were partners in crime, enjoying sleepovers at each otherâs homes and pulling pranks on their unsuspecting co-stars. Who would have thought that the fierce rivalry on screen would spark such a fun and playful friendship off-screen?
The Fallout of grief in âMy Ellenâ
One of the most memorable episodes of Little House on the Prairie is titled âMy Ellen,â which revolves around the tragic drowning of Ellen Taylor.
When Laura and Mary go skinny-dipping with their friend Ellen Taylor, they suddenly find themselves in a tricky situation. Some boys come by, prompting the girls to hide underwater until the coast is clear.
While Laura and Mary manage to resurface safely, Ellen tragically becomes trapped and drowns. The aftermath is heart-wrenching, as Ellenâs grief-stricken mother, in her sorrow, blames Laura for the tragedy.
During Ellenâs funeral, her mother is overwhelmed with sorrow and blames Laura for the tragedy, saying, âYOU did this!â This gut-wrenching accusation hits Laura hard, especially since she already feels guilty about what happened. What stands out, though, is how the adults around them react. Instead of stepping in to defend Laura, they only exchange worried glances and let her suffer alone in her pain.
Itâs a confusing moment. With so many adults present, including Reverend Alden and Doc Baker, youâd expect at least one of them to comfort Laura and reassure her that she isnât to blame. Instead, they leave her to grapple with the harsh words on her own. In âMy Ellen,â the emotional weight of the story is undeniable, but there are moments that feel disjointed in terms of storytelling
Michael Landon put frogs in his mouth
Pranks seemed to be a big part of the filming culture, and it was Michael Landon who often led the charge with his creative and funny antics. One hilarious prank was revealed by Rachel Greenbush, who played the youngest Ingalls sibling, Carrie.
The mischievous duo of Greenbush and her on-screen sister, Melissa Gilbert, would sneak off to the creek during breaks for some frog-catching adventures. With their slimy little friends in tow, theyâd return to the set to surprise Landon
In a playful twist, he would take the unsuspecting frogs and pop them in his mouth, then stroll over to fellow cast and crew members. With a cheeky grin, heâd open his mouth to let the frogs jump out, sending everyone around him into startled fits of laughter and panic.
Melissa Gilbertâs rift with Michael Landon
The cast had such great chemistry that youâd think they were a real family, and off-screen the co-stars were a big part of each otherâs lives for many years.
But things werenât always smooth between the actors, and one major incident caused a lasting rift between Melissa Gilbert and Michael Landon.
It all started when the young star discovered news that would forever change how she saw Landon. Landon, while married to his second wife Marjorie Lynn Noe, began an on-set affair with a much-younger woman, Little Houseâs makeup artist and stand-in Cindy Clerico.
Gilbert recalls noticing how close Landon and Clerico were becoming on set, but dismissed the thought, refusing to think Landon would cheat on his wife.
âIt was nothing untoward; they werenât ever in a closed-off room, not that I saw,â she wrote in her memoir. âBut Mike would walk around holding her puppy, and she was a pretty young thing who wore stylish tight jeans, leotards, and high-heel boots.â
Soon, the cast, including Gilbert, discovered the affair and were devastated by the actions of the actor they had looked up to as a father figure.
âFor us, as kids, it was a real blow,â Melissa Sue Anderson later recalled in her biography. âAlthough we knew he could be difficult at times and had his flaws, we never dreamed he was capable of inflicting that kind of pain on his real family.
âFor me personally, I had held him up to a higher moral standard. He had really let me down.â
The traveling quilt
Eagle-eyed fans with laser-like vision have spotted another hilarious blooper: the family quilt seems to have a mind of its own! This elusive quilt pops up in various locations throughout the series â on the Olsensâ bed, Charles and Carolineâs bed, and even on other charactersâ beds.
Mostly white with a charming design resembling a double wedding ring quilt, itâs clear that some props were reused for efficiency.
And speaking of locations, have you noticed the Ingalls childrenâs puzzling journey to and from school? Their route seems to change from episode to episode. Sometimes, they cross the bridge and stroll past the sawmill, while other times they mysteriously appear on the road behind it.